DUP-UU election pact: what could happen?

Despite spending much of the autumn of 2014 ruling out an election pact, the Democratic Unionist Party and the Ulster Unionists have this week gone ahead and agreed just that.

The DUP will not field candidates in Fermanagh & South Tyrone and Newry & Armagh, while the Ulster Unionists will not field candidates in Belfast East and Belfast North.

In each case, the party that is standing aside will encourage its supporters to vote for the other party’s candidate.

It’s an arrangement that is both pragmatic and political.

The most significant of the four seats is probably Belfast East. Naomi Long of the Alliance party won the constituency in 2010 by 1,533 votes. Both the DUP and the Unionists fielded candidates in that election, as they had done in every election since 1997. Long managed to beat both parties, in the process defeating DUP leader Peter Robinson.

This time the Ulster Unionists are standing aside in the hope that its supporters will swing behind the DUP candidate Gavin Robinson and in the process defeat Long.

You’d have to say this now seems a distinct possibility, though some voters may take umbrage at being denied a proper choice. A DUP gain in Belfast East would not just wipe out the Alliance party’s representation in the Commons. It would also boost the DUP’s numbers in the Commons by one, in turn giving the party more sway in a hung parliament.

The other seat in which the Ulster Unionists are standing aside is Belfast North: already a DUP seat, but one that Sinn Fein’s Gerry Kelly is hoping to take, having come only 2,224 votes behind Nigel Dodds in 2010. This year will be the fifth time Kelly has tried to take the seat for Sinn Fein. But if Ulster Unionist supporters swing behind Dodds, the DUP ought to retain the seat easily.

The two seats in which the DUP is standing aside probably won’t see any change. Both are currently held by Sinn Fein: Newry & Armagh, where Conor Murphy won a majority of 8,331 in 2010, and Fermanagh & South Tyrone, where Michelle Gildernew won by just four votes: the smallest majority in the whole of the UK.

Gildernew has experience of standing against a so-called “unity” candidate. In 2010 the DUP and Ulster Unionists both stood aside in her constituency and urged their supporters to back the independent candidate Rodney Connor. Gildernew still won, albeit by a tissue-thin margin.

My instinct is she will cling on again this year, but the result could be close. She has been the MP for the seat since 2001. Sinn Fein holds three of the assembly seats for the constituency, while the DUP has two and the Ulster Unionists one.

If the UU do win, however, it will mean the party will be back in the Commons for the first time since 2010. And it will almost certainly side with the Conservatives in any coalition or minority administration.

The DUP-UU pact is one that may only affect a tiny handful of seats, but it could have big consequences for the stability and composition of the next government.


4 responses to ‘DUP-UU election pact: what could happen?

  1. Conor Murphy retiring but I expect SF to hold Newry and Armagh and also Fermanagh & S Tyrone.

    Belfast E was the most surprising result of the last general election where Naomi Long defeated Peter Robinson who is not standing this time. Pact should confirm DUP gain. Belfast N should be the next seat to ultimately fall to Nationalists and this will be close but due to pact should result in DUP hold.

    Therefore NIshould end up 9DUP 1IND 5SF 3SDLP which is 10 Unionists and 8 Nationalists but if Dodds were to lose, then it would be tied at 9 each.

    Finally it will be interesting to see how many NI seats are contested by Conservatives.

  2. “Belfast N should be the next seat to ultimately fall to Nationalists”

    Unless it’s abolished (both Belfast and Ni overall are over-represented by one seat given constituency sizes by comparison with average across the country).

  3. From the outside, it looks like politics in Northern Ireland continues to be polarised between SF and the DUP.

    I guess the SDLP and UUP will soldier on at a reduced level in European elections, the NI Assembly, and local councils, but is there much chance of support swinging back to them?

  4. Cant see Kelly winning North Belfast. For starters, Dodds will be the only unionist candidate on the ballot. Kelly has to deal with an SDLP candidate for the nationalist vote. Secondly, older voters there are predominately unionist and will vote in droves to keep out the “fenian scumbag” to put it politely.
    Could only see Kelly winning if there’s an significantly increased turnout amongst nationalists and the SDLP vote utterly collapses.

    This is a pretty good overview of Fermanagh and South Tyrone and is as true now as it was 5 years ago.
    In any other place, Gildernew would win in a landslide. She’s charming, especially compared to her unionist opponent who has the charisma of a guano stained stone gargoyle, & is popular even amongst protestant farmers in a mainly rural constituency thanks to her time as Minister of Agriculture in the executive. Sadly for her its FST, a place where unionists are solely concerned with “exorcising the ghost of Bobby Sands, and raising the unionist flag again in border country”. She’ll hold on though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s